Hello dear
Welcome To Downtown Benny's Pizza
At Downtown Benny's Pizza, nestled in Fort Pierce, we celebrate the art of Italian cuisine through the passion and tradition of pizza-making. Our journey began with a simple goal: to serve delicious, authentic pizza crafted with fresh, gourmet toppings and flavorful sauces that resonate with our customers. We take pride in our handmade creations, from customizable pizzas and hearty calzones to flavorful wraps and sandwiches. Our commitment to quality doesn’t stop at food; we also offer accommodating dining options—indoor seating and dog-friendly policies. Join us for an unforgettable meal, where flavor and hospitality combine to create a true culinary experience.
About
Downtown Benny's Pizza
If you’re in Fort Pierce and craving a slice of authentic Italian pizza, look no further than Downtown Benny's Pizza. Nestled at 4919 Oleander Ave, this charming eatery offers a delightful fusion of classical flavors and modern culinary flair. With its mouth-watering menu, friendly atmosphere, and reasonable prices, it’s no wonder that patrons rave about their experiences.
Upon entering Downtown Benny’s, you're greeted by the warm, inviting scent of freshly baked dough and rich marinara sauce. Their standout offering, the pizza, has garnered accolades from many gracious diners. Customers like Damian, who hails from Jersey, proclaim, “This is good pizza done right.” The thick, hearty sauce is a crowd favorite, ensuring that you won’t leave feeling uneasy.
In addition to their renowned pizzas, such as the classic cheese and the enticing Benny's special, the menu boasts a variety of fresh sandwiches and wraps. Indulge in the Chicken Caesar Wrap or the delectable Turkey and Cheese Sub, both priced at $10.95, the perfect complement to your pizza experience. And don’t forget the kids! With options like Kids Chicken Fingers and Homemade Penne Alfredo, there’s something for everyone in the family.
For those with a sweet tooth, Downtown Benny's offers a selection of desserts that are hard to resist. From the rich Tiramisu at $5.95 to the classic Cannoli at $4.95, every bite promises to conclude your meal on a high note. And if you’re looking for a shareable treat, the Zeppolis are a must-try.
The customer reviews speak volumes about the dining experience here. Visitors like Seth highlight the great service and delicious food, while Michelle Giovannelli appreciates both the quality and the pricing. Friendly, attentive staff enhance the welcoming ambiance, contributing to an overall enjoyable visit.
As you dig into your meal, you might also want to try their garlic rolls, praised for their rich flavor - a house specialty that elevates the dining affair. While some diners noted the absence of a soda fountain, the canned drinks available are sufficient to quench your thirst.
If you're searching for a pizza parlor that combines excellent food, service, and family-friendly options, Downtown Benny's Pizza is the place to be. Don’t be surprised if, like many who have walked through its doors, you find yourself planning your next visit before you've even finished your meal!
For more information, or to place an order, call them at (772) 828-3057.
Book a table
Make A Reservation
“ Great food, great service, great prices! ”
“ Came here with my family. Great service. Got pizza baked ziti chicken. Alfredo, everything is delicious ”
“ Live in Jersey. This is good pizza done right. Sauce tastes great and is thick and heavy, and it wont give you heartburn, lol. ”
“ First time here and it was really good in my opinion. I would definitely come back here and bring other ppl as well. I really like the garlic rolls. The garlic butter was really good. Some places just chop up garlic and put in oil. We also had some hot wings. Interesting flavor or to much seasoning nonetheless I enjoyed them too. ”
“ Pizza was awesome. One of the best that we had in Florida. Only thing that they dont have is a soda fountain.They do offer cans of pepsi coke products however.We had cheesey garlic bread,it could of used a little more cheese but it still tasted good. We had a cheese sausage pizza a Bennys special pizza.Both were awesome.Staff was friendly. There is indoor eating which is a plus.Deffinately recommend this place. We will be back.Only wish they offered small size salads . ”
“ Ive never dinned in only delivery. Food is always hot n made with fresh ingredients. Ordered a few times now adding review with another happy delivery tonight ! Ps the Stromboli add spinach is to die for !! ”
“ Love the pizza here. Staff is cool and pizza is thin crust and crispy from middle to end.This bring back memories of my childhood in Brooklyn. Nice ratio of sauce and cheese. You have to try their white pizza with spinach and tomatoes. ”
“ Bennys Pizza is the best in taste, presentation and service. We saw it featured on Baldi Eats and had to check it out. We were not disappointed. My son had a peperoni pizza slice. He loved it, I couldnt help try some, it was amazing! I got a Greek salad it was crisp, fresh, and also huge! The garlic knots were just right. My husband had chicken parm, the serving size was huge and it was extra tasty. It also came with a side salad and garlic knots. We will definitely go again ”